Greenberg No Longer in the Company of Moonlight

Thirty years ago, even the most die-hard baseball fan would be hard-pressed to know of Archibald “Moonlight” Graham, an outfielder for the New York Giants in 1905. But the 1982 W.P. Kinsella novel “Shoeless Joe” uncovered his existence to a select group of followers. However, it wouldn’t be until 1989 when Kinsella’s novel would be made into the feature film “Field of Dreams” that Graham, and his plight, would become almost common knowledge among sports fans. The story of taking chances, living out dreams, and redemption provided a backdrop for what took center stage in Miami on Tuesday night.

But for those who still have yet to read the book or see the movie, here is a brief description. Moonlight Graham was a secondary character in the story of an Iowa corn farmer, listening to his dreams, plows his cornfield under to build a baseball diamond. The diamond brings back the ghost of “Shoeless” Joe Jackson, the banned outfielder form the 1919 Chicago White Sox. The farmer then sets off on a series of travels to bring others to the field. Among them was Graham, an outfielder for the New York Giants, who in 1905 was credited with a game appearance but never had an official at bat. While the ghost of Graham receives closure by playing in at the field, he forsakes his dream of being a big league ballplayer when an emergency summons him back to his true calling, that of a small town doctor.

In 2005, the Cubs were a .500 ball club working through some outfield issues when they called up a player named Adam Greenberg on July 7. Selected in the ninth round of the 2002 draft, Greenberg had spent four years in the Cubs’ system and had a career .284 batting average, 3.92 on-base percentage, and 77 stolen bases. It looked as if Greenberg might have a future as a big-leaguer, satisfying the problematic leadoff spot for the parent club.

He was to see his first Major League action as a pinch hitter in the ninth inning in a game on July 9 against the Florida Marlins. On the very first pitch he saw, Marlins pitcher Valerio De Los Santos hit Greenberg in the back of the head with a pitch. He suffered a concussion, which later would cause him vertigo and excruciating headaches. Greenberg was removed from the ballgame and spent the rest of the year on the disabled list. It remained his only Major League appearance until Tuesday.

While Greenberg battled to come back from the injury, he cleared many hurdles. Playing independent ball in 2009, Greenberg suffered yet another beaning and bounced back. In 2011, he was able to single off De Los Santos. Now 31-years old, the Miami Marlins made a gesture in which they hoped would wipe the slate clean. They signed Greenberg to a one-day contract with the expressed purpose of playing him on October 2, giving him an opportunity to bat.

Adam Greenberg decided to make the most of his contract, donating it to a charity doing research on concussions. In the sixth inning, Greenberg came up to face the Mets’ RA Dickey, pinch hitting for left fielder Bryan Peterson. Greenberg struck out swinging on three pitches. While some may wish the outcome would have had a happier ending, at least Greenberg didn’t have to appear in some literary cornfield to receive closure.

Follow ChicagoCubsOnline on Twitter: @TheCCO

Quote of the Day

"Whatever you think, be sure it is what you think; whatever you want, be sure that is what you want." – T.S. Eliot

Share on Fancred
  • Agustin

    I remember that day, in fact it was thoroughly covered by the CCO. Its incredible that Greenberg’s call up already 7 years ago! I believe he came up along with Matt Murton.

    In my book; The first thing the lowly Marlins ever did that deserve respect. (Other than the 2 WC)

    • Aaron


      Nice to see you again on here :)

      As for Greenberg’s call-up…..I actually believe once he was injured, Murton was recalled to replace him, but I could be mistaken.

      It’s a sad story. He wasn’t a great player by any means, but he was a pesky hitter. I’m just glad he got one more AB, even if it was a strikeout.

  • GaryLeeT

    I was at that game (and the Colvin stabbed by broken bat incident……hmmmm), and knew it was his first MLB at bat. My heart broke for him. It seems nobody is ever the same after getting hit in the head.

  • John_CC

    Nice piece, Tom. Very nice!

  • Tom U

    Thank you to everyone for your comments.

    • SuzyS

      Tom U…Nice job…thanks.

  • cubtex

    Now that I have stopped laughing from Theo’s vote of confidence for Dale Sveum……Saying that Dale has done a FANTASTIC job……I guess there is no point in talking about his job being in jeopardy for as long as Theo is employed by the Cubs. It is not easy losing 100 games. Yes….the Cubs suck and don’t have talent but to lose 100 games is historic. How has the team’s baserunning been this year? How has the sacrifice bunting been? Situational hitting? What is their record in 1 run games? How many times have they been shutout(and before everyone says that the manager doesn’t have anything to do with that doesn’t know baseball) How many walks has the pitching staff given up this year? What is their record on the road against NL West?(Remember Colorado and San Diego are in the NL West)
    So…….if Dale has done such a fantastic job this year…..what does he have to do to lose his job…….EVER? Nothing. He has as much job security as any manager in baseball.

  • SuzyS

    Cubtex, You take so much to heart. Do you really think you or any other mlb manager could have done much better…Given the Volsteds and Germanos we had to work with??? DeWitt for half a season???
    I’m neither a booster nor detractor for Sveum. He was a rookie manager given a hodgepodge of talent to work with.
    I really wanted Sandberg…but even he would have had a horrible time with this mess.
    You seem to miss the point…the Cubs lost by design…to position themselves to get the best talent they can through the draft. They did that.

  • Cubs 31

    Am disappointed that the Cubs did not give Greenberg a one day contract. At least the Cubs can give him an invite to the Cubs Convention. Come on Theo, invite him to the Cubs Convention. At least he was a player in the Cubs organization.

  • cubtex

    Suzy, I am responding to Theo’s assesment of the job Svuem has done. He used the word FANTASTIC. This is not about wins and losses but development. Who has been developed? What improvements did Sveum make to help the team improve in 2013? Please explain to me how Sveum has done a FANTASTIC job?