Decisions, Decisions and More Decisions Ahead for the Cubs

Vote 0 Votes

Will Matt Capps choose the Nationals or the Cubs? Is Marlon Byrd still an option for centerfield? What about second base? The bench?

The Cubs are expected to hear by Wednesday night on Matt Capps' decision on whether he will close for the Nationals ... or set-up Carlos Marmol on the North Side. According to multiple reports the former Pirate is expected to sign with either the Cubs or Nationals before Christmas Eve. Capps' former teammate, John Grabow, made contact with Capps trying to recruit him to sign with the Cubs.

In the wake of the Melky Cabrera-Javier Vazquez trade between the Yankees and Braves, the Cubs will continue to explore free agent options and possible trading partners to fill their need for a centerfielder.

Bruce Levine thinks the Cubs will be very active over the next ten days ... here's the latest from the mill.

Chatting with Bruce Levine

Mr. Talkin' Baseball held his weekly chat on ESPN Chicago Tuesday afternoon. The always-informative Bruce Levine tossed a couple of new names into the rumor mill. Here are the highlights:

  • Starlin Castro has been compared to Hanley Ramirez ... but at 19 it is hard to make a true comparison to the Marlins' shortstop. Castro could be with the Cubs by mid to late 2010.
  • The Cubs are looking at rehab pitchers Kelvim Escobar and Ben Sheets.
  • Levine is hearing Aroldis Chapman is looking for four years and around $35 million, which is too much for the Cubs.
  • Levine thinks the Cubs listened to the Indians about possibly trading for Kerry Wood ... but he thinks the Wood "ship has sailed" with the Cubs.
  • Carlos Silva will have every chance to fail with the Cubs before they would release him. Silva is slotted to compete for the fifth spot in the rotation ... but could end up in the pen.
  • Reed Johnson wants to come back to the Cubs.
  • The Cubs were interested in Javier Vazquez.
  • Scott Podsednik is looking for a three-year deal in the neighborhood of $12 million ($4 million per season).
  • According to Levine, "it is believed that management will allow Hendry to spend more dollars to fill the roster for 2010."
  • The Cubs like Orlando Hudson ... but he is not the Cubs' priority right now. The Cubs are looking to add a bullpen arm and a centerfielder.
  • The Cubs were very interested in Melky Cabrera.
  • Jim Hendry will investigate the trade market and free agents over the next couple of weeks. Levine thinks Hendry will be extremely aggressive, even during the holidays.
  • The Cubs might consider Jose Contreras to fill the final spot in the rotation.
  • The Cubs would love to trade Kosuke Fukudome ... but there is no market. "There was some thought that he could go in a trade to the Yankees, who are losing a lot of Japanese revenue now that Matsui is playing in Anaheim. That trade is not going to happen now."
  • Levine tossed out the idea of trading Kosuke Fukudome for Nick Swisher. Later Levine pointed out the two teams have not discussed the trade. Swisher was the back-up plan for the Cubs had Fukudome signed elsewhere two winters ago.
  • Scouts that Levine has spoken to about Josh Vitters think he will hit at the big league level ... but could end up being a first baseman.
  • The Ricketts family really likes Ryne Sandberg and he could be the Cubs' manager once Lou Piniella decides to hang 'em up.

Matt Capps

Matt Capps' agent, Paul Kinzer, told Bruce Levine that his client would make a decision by Wednesday night.

One thing is certain Matt Capps is about to get paid.

The Cubs and Nationals are looking to sign Capps to a two-year contract and it appears the deal will be worth around $8 million.

The Nationals were not originally on Capps' radar but they have pushed very hard to sign him according to a report from ESPN. If Capps wants to remain a closer, he will sign with the Nationals.

According to a report from Cubs.com, John Grabow told Capps that he might not sign with the Cubs as a closer "but things happen."

Grabow described Capps as a bulldog and a guy willing to take the ball everyday.

Marlon Byrd

The Cubs are still interested in signing Marlon Byrd. According to a report from ESPN, the Cubs remain the favorite to sign Byrd. The Cubs think Byrd will continue to hit outside of Texas due to the influence of Rudy Jaramillo. Byrd views Jaramillo as his mentor.

Apparently Byrd is looking for too much money. Bruce Levine said the Cubs could sign both Byrd and Matt Capps ... but "it depends on how soon Byrd's agents will bring down his request to a more realistic amount."

The Braves are one of the other teams rumored to be interested in signing Marlon Byrd.

Marlon Byrd is represented by Seth and Sam Levinson ... the same agents as Milton Bradley.

Jim Duquette (XM Radio) made a bold statement about Marlon Byrd on Tuesday. Duquette said, "Marlon Byrd reeks of Aaron Rowand." Duquette does not feel Byrd will live up to the contract he is about to sign.

Centerfield Candidates?

Phil Rogers is at it again. Rogers said the Cubs have been exploring trades for centerfielders and questioned if Jim Hendry would try to reacquire Felix Pie.

Marlon Byrd, Scott Podsednik, Rick Ankiel and Reed Johnson were the other names brought up by Rogers.

As always, take the blurb from Rogers about Felix Pie with a grain of salt.

Minor Signing

The Cubs signed non-drafted free agent Derek Helenihi according to the transaction column on Baseball America. The third baseman played along side D.J. LeMahieu on the College World Series Champion Louisiana State University squad.

Derek Helenihi's Page on the Baseball Cube

The Cubs released Erik Hamren (RHP), Bill Muldowney (RHP), George Pineda (RHP), Jayson Ruhlman (RHP) and Melvin Vazquez (LHP).

Finally ... Barry Rozner asked the question: Could Girardi wind up on the Cubs' radar? Joe Girardi is a "free agent" after the 2010 season ...

Follow the CCO on Twitter ...

If you don't have an account on the CCO ... sign-up for one to share your thoughts and interact with the rest of the Faithful.

Well, that's the latest ... and I am sticking to it!

  • dan

    Has any one watched Ankiel play the last two years? Yuck!! Out of the four centerfielders I take speedy Pods and his world series ring

  • SuzyS

    Actually, if Guzman is healthy...we don't need Capps...so I'm ok with it...but it does seem as if Hendry is either discounting Guzman or planning on trading him.



    Just another onr track thought...EY Jr has played center.



    AS a low cost option...I would not mind seeing Pie in center...he seemed to be coming around last season towards the end...and he has always been awesome defensively.

    But because the rumor came from "Mr. Rodgers" I consider it already dead.



    But overall...I'm with Neil re Brad Snyder...He could possibly have a Casey McGehee type year in the outfield if given a shot.

  • Aaron F

    Looks like Capps may be going with the Nationals:



    http://sports.espn.go.com/mlb/news/story?id=4768894

  • Neil

    Yep ... thanks for posting. Beat me to it.

  • Aaron F

    Sorry Neil. :)

  • Neil

    No apologies necessary. I appreciated you posting the link.



    This site is about passing on info ... doesn't matter who does it.

  • D

    Jerljr... it's Reed Johnson.



    and I understand after the 100+ years why everyone is so pessimistic, but wow you guys are just doubting players before we even see them hit the field! Matt Capps would be a great sign he's 26 with a career Era of 3.61 not too bad considering 1 bad outing kills RP's ERAs. With Marmol's stuff and Grabows crafty ability, you plug this guy in the 8th inning with good experience you'r going to have one of the better bullpens in the league. As for Marlon Byrd, we'll have to wait and see, he's getting up there in age so I'm not going to say he'll be the savior but nontheless more productive than what we did have in years past.

  • jerljr

    Oh yeah, have a Merry Christmas and ask Santa for a Championship.

  • jerljr

    Caps is probably our best option. I wish he wasn't. So I do believe we should sign him.



    I like the idea about signing Sheets. But only of of past years. Not sure what he would do now.



    And yes, sign Russ Johnson. But for a fourth outfielder not a starter.

  • jerljr

    I would be OK with Podsednik. He always seemed to get that timely hit when needed against us. And seems to play hard. But he is getting old and defense is questionable.



    Overall guys I'm not too excited about this year. I dont feel comfortable with Capps closing or being a set up man, Marmol disappointed me last year with his control. Maybe he will do better this year. I believe are bullpen will suck unless some people step up. Starting rotation leaves something to desire. Offense is mismatched.



    There's always signings that can happen or players stepping up but as of right now, I dont like the team.



    I think we should of tried harder to get Derosa. I just like that guy. But I like having a bunch of good team guys that dont complain about there rolls and do what is needed to win. He fit into that.

  • woody34

    Neil,

    I saw that before the Vasquez deal that the Cubs were willing to take Igawa? Did you hear anything about this? What it would of cost us? etc

  • Neil

    I had not heard that rumor before the tweet this morning



    http://twitter.com/BloggingBombers/status/6964558305



    All I can say is please no! What a bust he has been.

  • MEHATEHENDRY

    Guys, we're gonna stink next year. Capps, Ankiel? really?



    Hendry better hope for some kind of miracle for the team to be really good next year. Right now i'm just hoping that some of the younger players come out of nowhere and contribute.

  • Jim C (Tinley Park, IL)

    Is everyone nervously awaiting the Matt Capps decision? LOL

  • Neil

    Here ya go Jim ...



    Update on Capps ... sometime before midnight.



    http://espn.go.com/chicago/columns/blog/_/post/4768403/name/levine

  • Jim C (Tinley Park, IL)

    I bet that you will be up tracking this. The CCO is 24/7 We never close operation.

  • Neil

    Exactly!

  • agustin rexach

    Lolololol !!!! Very good stuff by Jim! Good job Neil!

  • joe d

    How come all those fans who were so sad when Pie got traded aren't trying to stoke the flames of this rumor? Could it be he's just not that good? BTW how's Rich Hill doing these days without Piniella breathing down his neck, keeping him from throwing strikes?

  • Steve Stoned

    Pie needs to play. He was never going to get enough at bats here & still wouldn't. He may end up producing. He might not. But he needs to be somewhere where he can get the opportunity. That's not happening here.

  • woody34

    Ankiel makes the most sense for centerfield for a couple years until Jackson or whomever steps up is ready. Rudy Jaramillo has already said he could improve his batting average by 30 to 40 points. That would provide our centerfield position a 270 avg with 30 hr potential, a great arm for a center fielder, and decent range.



    The Cubs do not need an aging, overweight center fielder roaming around out there in Byrd. I hope Hendry's mancrush does not bring him in like some other moves he has made have(i.e. Heilman).



    My question is who is the fifth outfielder? Soriano, Fuld, and Fukudome are on the 25 man roster. Hendry signs Ankiel that makes four, is it a battle in spring training or is the job given to Colvin?

  • Neil

    Good points on Byrd. Hendry tried to trade for him before Reed Johnson fell into his lap before the 2008 season.



    As for Jaramillo and Ankiel, the 30-40 point increase is what the Cubs think Jaramillo could do for Ankiel ... via Bruce Levine.



    As the bench is currently contructed, the five extra players would be:



    Koyie Hill

    Jeff Baker

    Micah Hoffpauir

    Andres Blanco

    Sam Fuld



    They are going to play Baker in the outfield corner spots a lot in the spring. The Cubs really feel he could be the next Mark DeRosa.



    Baker would serve as back-ups to second and third. Hoffpauir at first and in the outfield and Blanco up the middle.



    Fuld would be the fourth outfielder.



    The bench is very concerning. I would rather see them re-sign Brad Snyder and see what he can do in the spring.



    He performed well last year before he got hurt and could give the Cubs a more versatile player than Hoffpauir.



    Snyder is a true outfielder with a very good arm (I have seen him play, not just what I have read). He could be used as a defensive replacement for Soriano and could take over for Fukudome in case he has to be lifted for a pinch hitter. Bottom line, I think Snyder would give Piniella more options.



    Hoffpauir would be a pinch hitter only.



    With Baker the Cubs would have a back-up to Lee if he got hurt during the game. Hoffpauir would not be an improvement in left over Soriano. And you do not want Hoffpauir's defense in right late in a close game. Unless Lee is hurt or they are giving him a day off, Hoffpauir will sit.



    Snyder is a free-agent and I have been watching the wire to see when he has signed ...



    Brad Snyder is a better option.

  • mg

    now that the A's have crisp to play cf, i wonder if davis would be available. i would love to see him leading off & playing cf if the cubs could get him for s package like marshall & colvin.

  • Neil

    Good call on Rajai Davis. The Cubs were rumored to be interested in him last year.



    .305/.360/.423/.784 with an OPS+ of 108 last year in 125 games with 27 doubles and 41 stolen bases ... caught 12 times.



    Plus there is a long history between Hendry and Billy Beane.



    I have not heard about him being available...but you could be onto something. He will play 2010 at 29 ... turns 30 on October 19.

  • PaulS

    How about Ryan Sweeney? I just have a feeling Rudy could increase the power in this kids swing. I guess then your leadoff man would need to come from second base.

  • Leeeee

    I am hopeful that the Cubs get Capps. With his addition, the bull pen will be pretty stout. Marmol, Capps, Grabow, and Guzman all appear to be exceptional relievers. No team would want to go into the late innings down against those guys, that's a pretty powerful thing.



    Additionally, I will continue to state that the Cubs should focus on Signing Felipe Lopez. He is the one guy that fills the Cubs greatest offensive need. None of the availible centerfielders are capable of that. Defence to me is the only thing that matters in CF. I think Reed Johnson, Sam Fuld would be fine out there. Hell bring back Doug Dascenzo for all I care just get LOPEZ!

  • Chris

    I like the Dascenzo idea.. We could use him as a spot reliever too!!

  • PaulS

    The only thing about Lopez I don't understand is that it seems like he has been getting passed around like a bad cold the past few years. I agree it seems like he does nothing but hit the ball, but teams don't keep him. 05 is a little suspicious too with 25hrs and never came close to that again.



    I just wonder if there is some thing teams know that the average fan is unware.

  • Leeeee

    I see what you are saying about Lopez' odd year. I don't think his HR totals are what's going to land him a contract. The reasons I think he is THE guy is because he seems to be a guy that is still on the way up. If you look at his OBP and OPS they have rizen steadily over the past 3 years presumably without the HGH that he may have been taking in '05. He is also only 29. Two and a half years shy of the dreaded age 32. Lopez and Hudson are fairly comperable but Lopez's age means a lot. Don't get me wrong though, Hudson on a one year deal wouldn't disappoint me. I would rather see Lopez on a two or three year deal.

  • joe d

    Would a Fuld / Johnson platoon really be so bad? When was the last time Johnson got the majority of CF plate appearances in a season? Seems like he's always hovering in that .280 - .300 range. And, hell, he wants to be a Cub. His price will probably be cheaper than all the other options, so maybe Hudson becomes a possibility?

  • woody34

    If you play a platoon of LH Fuld and RH Johnson, then Johnson would not be getting the majority of playing time. If you resign Johnson it would be to platoon with Fukudome.

  • joe d

    That's right I forgot Fuld can't hit lefties.

  • Ronald

    You right but we are talking about Jim Hendry who is possibly the worst general manager of the century.

  • Ronald

    I think all Carlos Silva will do for us is be bad and eat innings. Neil what do you think?

  • Mike

    If Hendry signs Ankiel, I'll jump out a window, now I understand that Johnson wants to be a Cub, I love his hustle and his approach at the plate, he has become since a player that was just dropped off by Toronto, a real fan fav in Chicago, I would def love to see him again in a Cub uniform platooning with a younger player, while we focus on obtaining hopefully Hudson or Felipe Lopez, Baker is a nice backup but we need to trade away Fontenot for a christmas stocking or whatever...

  • Ronald

    Hendry makes many of us want to jump out a window.

  • agustin rexach

    I think Ankiel could be a nice short term solution. He is great defensively and if he is somewhere in between 08' and 09' he'll be a huge run producer.

  • Ronald

    I completely agree.

  • PaulS

    The problem with Ankiel is his agent is Scott Boras so he'll be seeking a maximized contract on dollars and years.

    I think it would be in Ankiel's best interest to sign a 1yr incentive based deal with the Cubs because I think he could really thrive in Wrigley. Additionally, if Rudy could help him, he could greatly increase his value and then go back out on the FA market again next year.

  • Neil

    Excellent point

  • SantoFever09

    Neil,



    Who do YOU think would be the Cubs best option for CF?



    Marlon Byrd

    Rick Ankiel

    Scott Podsednik

    Reed Johnson



    Obviously, each player has their advantages and disadvantages. Also, do you think in the end it will come down to price rather than skill?

  • Neil

    Sorry for the delay in responding today guys ...



    Is 'none of the above' an option?



    Of the four they are rumored to be interested in, I would think Ankiel. He is younger, has a bigger upside and would be better defensively.



    If Ankiel could stay healthy, which is a concern, the outfield defense in center and right would be very, very good. Left field, well...



    Shaun would like to have Podsednik. While the Cubs need a leadoff hitter, his defense is very Juan-Pierre-like.



    I agree with Jim Duquette, Marlon Byrd could be this year's version of Aaron Rowand. Some team is going to pay a lot to watch him decline.



    I have stated repeatedly I would like to see the Cubs get younger, instead of trying to fill needs from year to year. Byrd is the definition of fitting a need this year ... but what will they be left with.



    Ankiel on a one-year deal with an option might be a good solution. Allow him to work with Jaramillo and see what happens. But as PaulS pointed out, his agent is Scott Boras.



    I have heard he is looking to sign Ankiel to a "big contract" but I have not heard/read numbers or amount of years.



    As for Reed ... I like him as much as everyone else. I think he is a baseball player and always seems to be in the middle of a win. My concerns are his age, how much he will cost and his health.



    With the way Fuld hits lefties, I think the Cubs could get similar production out of Fuld ... with better speed and better defense off the bench.

  • Ronald

    I believe Rich Ankiel or Marlon Byrd will be better for CF because they have the most power and the cubs need power. Scott Podsednik and Reed Johnson is very good players but they will not provide us with the pop that we need.

blog comments powered by Disqus







CCO Twitter Updates




Shop WrigleyvilleSports.com Today!


Twitter Sports

Cubs on Twitter

Displaying tweets tagged with #Cubs

via twitter sports net


Recent Comments


Chicago Cubs Online - Featured On The Web Here

Chicago Cubs Online - one of Chicago's best blogs
Chicago Cubs Online - on Chicago Sun Times Chicago Cubs Online - on Sports Illustrated

ChicagoCubsOnline on YouTube