On Again or Off Again?

Vote 0 Votes

Is Jim Hendry still interested in trading for Brian Roberts? Has he stepped up his pursuit and has also targeted Erik Bedard? Is Matt Murton heading to Texas or San Diego? Could Jason Marquis be involved in a deal with the Orioles? What about Marlon Byrd? So many questions and so many rumors.

A day after the conclusion of the Convention the rumor mill kicked into high gear, fueled mostly by a report from Phil Rogers, but Ken Rosenthal had a hand in it as well. Jim Hendry shot down rumors on Saturday morning of a proposed trade with the Orioles that could have included both Roberts and Bedard in a 9-player deal. There were indications on Sunday, all talks were dead....once again, but the way it looks, these rumors will keep surfacing until Opening Day or a deal for one or both of the players is completed.

The Cubs agreed to a 1-year, $860,000 contract with Michael Wuertz on Monday to avoid arbitration. Wuertz was the last arbitration eligible player for the Cubs this off-season.

Here is the latest round of rumors, plus news and notes from around the league....

The Cubs

Erik Bedard and Brian Roberts

Rumors surrounding Jim Hendry possibly trading for Bedard and Roberts surfaced once again on Monday. Ken Rosenthal talked about the likelihood of the Cubs being able to trade for both players on Baseball This Morning.

According to Rosenthal, the Orioles have put a self-imposed timetable to deal Roberts and Bedard by the end of the month or keep them and attempt to trade them during the season. He thinks the Cubs are still pursuing Roberts but he does not feel they have enough to acquire Bedard in the same deal. Rosenthal said the Cubs would have to come up with a similar deal that the Tigers traded to the Marlins for Dontrelle Willis and Miguel Cabrera....and Rosenthal said the Cubs do not have prospects near the caliber of both Andrew Miller and Cameron Maybin.

Phil Rogers stated Peter Angelos shot down the rumored "7-2" deal over the weekend. Rogers reported the talks are back on. He cited a "very highly placed source, which means it is making the rounds of baseball's decision makers." Rogers speculated a three-team deal that involved the Rangers and Orioles could net the Cubs Roberts, Bedard and Marlon Byrd.

Bruce Miles released a report late on Monday afternoon and basically shot down Phil Rogers. Miles said Hendry is still working "on possible trades but informed insiders say no renewed talks are under way for a blockbuster with the Baltimore Orioles that would bring pitcher Erik Bedard and second baseman Brian Roberts to Chicago."

Dave Kaplan reported on Monday night that teams have seen medical records on Bedard....one of those teams being the Cubs. Kaplan said he was told, "They are not as solid as you would think." Phil Rogers briefly mentioned the Cubs are "worried about Bedard's medicals"....most think Bedard is fine. Two medical concerns on the same day, interesting.

The Baltimore Sun reported the Cubs "would be willing to part" with Rich Hill in a deal for Roberts and Bedard. According to the Sun, the Cubs do not have the prospects in order to land both in the same trade. The Sun stated the Mariners would be able to offer a better package.

According to a report in the Sun-Times "forget about" the Cubs landing both Roberts and Bedard....there is not enough in the farm system.

Matt Murton

According to multiple reports on Monday last weekend's Cubs Convention could be the last public appearance for Matt Murton as a Chicago Cub. Bruce Miles reported, "Hendry is actively shopping outfielder Matt Murton."

Ken Rosenthal reported late Monday night, the San Diego Padres have targeted Matt Murton as a possible fit to fill their need for a left fielder. Murton could be involved in a deal with the Orioles for Brian Roberts, according to Rosenthal, or the Cubs might want to keep Murton in case another outfielder is dealt to Baltimore.

Marlon Byrd

The Cubs appear very interested in acquiring Marlon Byrd from the Rangers, but at what price? The Cubs and Byrd have been linked together for the last three weeks, those rumors gained a little momentum over the weekend and then hit the absurd level on Monday.

According to Bruce Miles, "the Cubs like Texas outfielder Marlon Byrd." Jim Hendry mentioned numerous times during the convention he is looking to add a right-handed outfielder before Spring Training. Byrd would fit those needs and would be a good fit with the Cubs in a platoon role....but not at the ridiculous price reported by Phil Rogers.

According to Rogers, "The rumor in Texas involved Byrd for Matt Murton, but others say the deal would be Byrd for two or three players, including Murton. The Rangers, like the Orioles, apparently want pitching prospect Sean Gallagher to be in the deal."

If these rumors turn out to be true, the Cubs have more than overpaid for Byrd, but at the same time, by Rogers reporting the possible cost of Byrd being Murton, Gallagher and maybe another player....he has hurt the value of both Matt Murton and Sean Gallagher. The Cubs should receive a prospect, along with Byrd from the Rangers for Matt Murton....not the other way around.

Gordon Wittenmyer stated in the Sun-Times, the "Byrd moves looks possible, if not probable."

Jason Marquis

According to Ken Rosenthal, Jason Marquis could be involved in a deal with the Orioles for Brian Roberts. The Orioles view Marquis as an innings eater....other clubs have expressed interest in Marquis since the signing of Jon Lieber.

How about them Odds?

According to a report in the Detroit Free Press, the Cubs are 10/1 favorites to win the World Series....tops among all National League teams.

From Around the League

Former Cub, Jody Gerut, signed a minor league deal with the Padres on Monday.

According to multiple reports, the White Sox agreed to terms on a 2-year deal worth $11 million dollars with Octavio Dotel.

The Cardinals rewarded Yadier Molina on Monday with a 4-year, $15.5 million dollar deal.

Dayn Perry thinks the Reds "could make noise" in the upcoming season....and he is not alone.

Finally....the CCO participated in a Bloggers Roundtable at Baseball Digest Daily. If you have a chance, take a look and leave your comments. They have a very informative site.

  • Jim (Tinley Park)

    Joe:



    That is a good lineup, If The Riot could handle the lead off spot, that would work.

  • Joe

    Pie should hit 8th. My Perfect Line-up would be:



    Theriot SS

    Fukudome RF

    Lee 1B

    Ramirez 3B

    Soriano LF

    Soto C

    DeRosa 2B

    Pie CF

    Pitcher

  • eddie

    It just puts more pressure on Pie.

  • Jim (Tinley Park)

    If today was opening day this is my lineup:



    LF Soriano

    CF Pie

    1b Lee

    3b Ramirez

    Rf Fukudome

    2b DeRosa

    c Soto

    SS Theriot

    P Zambrano



    Pie needs protection, he will get nothing to swing at batting eighth. Actually, I wouldn't mind seeing him try hitting 1st and Soriano 2nd.

  • BD

    Well, I guess we will know where Bedard and Roberts are playing in a week and a few days. Let's hope one or both lands with the Cubs. This has been one stressful off-season, but it has been enjoyable. Even though I do not post that much, I have thoroughly enjoyed racing to the computer everyday after work, and reading the posted articles, updates, and reader comments. Now we can only HOPE (i've been listening to way to many Barack speeches) that Hendry makes the deal that we have been so patiently waiting for.



    In regards to Pie, I think he needs to play everyday and bat 8th in the order. He was yanked up and down last year, and didn�t have the opportunity to adjust to major league pitching or the lifestyle. If he can win the position coming out of ST, which I don't think will be a problem, we will have the opportunity to watch the evolution of a very special ball player.

  • Jason B. from AZ

    Phil Rogers strikes again...from his latest column on the trib online:



    "So why is the American League so dominant in recent years? Follow the money.



    Despite having two fewer teams, the AL is currently in line to spend $222 million more than the National League on salaries in 2008. The 14 AL teams average $102.1 million in payroll; the 16 NL teams average $75.5 million.



    This is not just about the Yankees and Red Sox, either. Take them out of the equation and the AL average is $85.8 -- more than $10 million per team more than the NL average."



    Perhaps it has a little something to do with the designated hitter? Duh...



    Add a salary for a good DH, and that gets you to $5-10M/yr. Examples are Jim Thome, Big Papi, Jason Giambi, etc...



    Not all DH's make big money, but just adding that full-time player, by default, raises the amount you are spending on your hitters.



    This, in turn, creates a need for even better pitching, as pitchers have to face 9 hitters, not 8 hitters and a pitcher, so the need for top pitching is even more pronounced in the AL. When you have fewer teams in your league, it is more critical to have top talent...the more teams in the league, the more diluted the talent can be. As a result, my guess is that the avg salaries for starting pitchers is higher in the AL, than in the NL.





    I need Phil Rogers job...he just seems to mail it in regularly, with no real thought behind what he is writing.

  • agustin rexach

    Lew I agree with your assessments. BUT, let me tell you that the only better defender than Pagan on this team would probably be Felix Pie. Angel is a true CF and can play the 3 spots. I like the Fuku signing a lot and I think he is definitely an upgrade but he is not a better defender than Pagan, believe me.

  • Lew

    jerljr: I disagree. I think this team is improved from last year. As of now though, the improvements may only be on defense.



    * Fukudome in right field will be better than Murton, Floyd, Jones, Pagan, Monroe, Ward or DeRosa. (Am I forgeting anyone?)



    * Pie as a center fielder is better than Soriano (Obviously), Jones, Pagan or Monroe. Not to mention that Fuld, this winter, has been called the teams best defensive outfielder.



    * Soto will be better than Barrett, Hill and Kendall. And I also like the idea of him being tuitored by Hank White.



    * This offseason has also added more arms for the rotation.



    The improvements on D should allow opponents fewer runs than last year. So the question is whether fewer runs allowed will translate into more wins.



    P.S. Even if Pie has a horrid start to the season at the plate, could it really be worse than how Jones has started the last couple of years?

  • jerljr

    I want to make one more comment



    As far as Fuko goes. I expect him this year not to have a great impact. He will have number a little better than Jones had last year. In the long run, he will earn his money.



    But, he was a great signing. He was an investment. They opened the Cubs to a whole new market that will make the Cubs alot more money than they paid for him. Which, in turn, will open up more possibilities in the free agent market, so one and so forth. Possibly even compete with the Red Sox and Yankees in signing key free agents. And yes, eventually a World series championship.

  • jerljr

    LOL TO BARRY......



    There is a lot of tension in Cubland because if they dont make a move, if this trade falls through, does anybody believe the team we have right now could make the World Series? My opinion, no. Fuko seems to be only a upgrade over what we had last year in RF but not enough to make that much of a difference. Honestly with Pie in center(unless he has a breakthrough) this team may not be as good as last year. We need this trade or one similar if not better. If we get the people that are rumored, that all changes. I think we need Badard(or other pitcher of the same caliber) and Byrd at the least. Roberts would be great but we could handle Derosa at second. But when one of the outfielders get hurt, we will be in trouble. The way it looks right now, our bench will be weaker than last year also. Plus Soto isn't a gaurentee. He looked great against lefties last year but didn't really play that much against right handers last year. Thats still an unknown. We'll compete for the division but without some upgrades we wont go any farther than that. Just my opinion.

  • Barry

    Gentlemen,

    I believe I have already informed you that both Bedard and Roberts will be CUBS by OD. Apparantly I left out Marlon Byrd. He's a good for average hitter who will play evryday CF because PIE will be a part of any three way deal or MEGA deal with Baltimore.



    Breathe everyone..... breathe......

  • Lows

    Basically I'm saying we need to keep Hill because he is one pitch away from being a great pitcher

  • Lows

    If Hill could develop a change-up, he could be one of the best pitchers in the NL, maybe even the game. His best pitch is without a doubt his curveball, followed by a well placed letter-high fastball or surprising inside in a curveball count. His over the top delivery allows for a very effective Change-up without jeopardizing his mechanics. If he were a low 3/4 guy or lower, a change-up is a tough pitch to learn because of the slot and positioning of his release. Because he has a high 3/4 to over the top arm slot his fastball doesn't move very much, but this will allow him to do nothing more than find a comfortable change-up grip and throw it. Sounds too easy, but I never developed a change-up until my senior year of college. I was a 3/4 to low 3/4 guy and a changeup was difficult to learn, especially being effective without one my whole life. I had to toy around with my arm slot to be able to throw one with comfort and confidence, he wont. If he could mix in a changeup in a fastball count, his Ks would be higher, he would get more ground balls, as well as his HR allowance would be down. He gives up bombs because his letter-high turns into a belt high without movement at 90mph making it a very very hittable pitch. His curveball will still be his best pitch, but as a lefty, he really needs to develop an average to good change-up. I'm surprised he really is as effective as he is without one....

  • Dave in STL

    Is there any way we can trade w/ Seattle for Adam Jones? How bout we wax all this Oriole BS and get him... J/K, I know that WONT happen but I'm tired of hearing McFail talk already... quit the schizophrenia act Andy and make a deal! I don't care at this point if that deal is w/ Seattle, Cincy, or Toledo for that matter... JUST FREAKING DO IT....

  • jerljr

    I got a feeling, unless its a three team deal, that Rich Hill will be included in this deal. I know that Baltimore is dumping salary, but the fans will crucify them for trading two key players for a bunch of prospects before the season starts. Rich Hill is the only one of the names mentioned that has established that he can contribute this season. Marshall, Gallagher possibly. If Hill is included, then I'm not for this deal. Marshall or Gallagher or both, OK.



    Hill isn't the prospect that Woods and Prior were but he does seem to be on his way to be a very effective major league pitcher.

  • Lew

    The only explaination for sending 3 players (including Murton) to Texas for Byrd would be that its part of a 3 team swap. The other likely being the Orioles. But then again, maybe I'm so far out there that Phil Rogers himself couldn't have made this stuff up.

  • jerljr

    I agree, I think this is all politics to get a better deal.

  • Jeff in AZ

    I think unless it comes from Hendry's mouth we can't accept it as truth. McPhail wants everyone to think a Roberts/Bedard deal is in the works so he can drive up the price for Bedard with Seattle. I would be suprise if either Roberts or Bedard are members of the Cubs, althought they would be welcome by me.

blog comments powered by Disqus







CCO Twitter Updates




Shop WrigleyvilleSports.com Today!


Twitter Sports

Cubs on Twitter

Displaying tweets tagged with #Cubs

via twitter sports net


Recent Comments


Chicago Cubs Online - Featured On The Web Here

Chicago Cubs Online - one of Chicago's best blogs
Chicago Cubs Online - on Chicago Sun Times Chicago Cubs Online - on Sports Illustrated

ChicagoCubsOnline on YouTube